PDA

View Full Version : New holiday for Emperor?



nicojo
22nd May 2005, 02:01
From the online Washington Post (http://www.washingtonpost.com)

----
Japan to Honor Wartime Emperor
Lawmakers Approve Controversial New National Holiday

By Anthony Faiola
Washington Post Foreign Service
Saturday, May 14, 2005; Page A17

TOKYO, May 13 -- Japanese legislators overwhelmingly approved a controversial bill Friday creating a national holiday to honor Hirohito, emperor of Japan during World War II, a move that critics called the latest in a series of steps to glorify Japan's militaristic past.

By a vote of 202 to 14, the upper house of Japan's parliament passed the bill to give the country a day off on Hirohito's April 29 birthday. The lower house approved the bill last month.

The holiday -- which takes effect in 2006 -- will be known as "Showa Day," after the official name for Hirohito's reign, which lasted from 1926 to 1989. Showa means "enlightened peace."

The bill had been scrapped twice because of political pressure and public criticism, but on the third try, it sailed through parliament, at a time of strong diplomatic tensions with Asian neighbors over Japan's wartime record.

Many analysts saw the bill, sponsored by the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, as part of a broad shift away from the county's post-World War II pacificism.

The Education Ministry last month approved a new version of a textbook that critics at home and abroad say whitewashes Japan's aggression in Asia. Japan has begun to assert more vigorously claims over disputed islands and waters that were lost after its defeat in World War II.

Polls show that the Japanese increasingly feel that their country, which has the world's second-largest economy, deserves a global role commensurate with its financial might, including a permanent seat on the U.N. Security Council. And there is pressure to modify terms in Japan's U.S.-drafted constitution that renounce war.

Opposition to a more assertive Japan has sparked new tensions with East Asian countries that were victims of Tokyo's aggression, particularly China and South Korea. Last month, demonstrators staged violent anti-Japanese protests at many Japanese diplomatic facilities and businesses in China. Thousands of South Koreans protested against Japan in March.

On Friday, Japanese opponents of the Showa Day bill condemned its passage. "The ruling Liberal Democratic Party wants to promote nationalism through this," said Seiji Mataichi, an upper house lawmaker from the Social Democratic Party and one of the handful of legislators who opposed the bill. He noted that debate continues over Hirohito's wartime responsibility.

"Why, in this, the 60th anniversary of the end of the war, do we have to create a Showa Day?" he asked. "This is inviting opposition from neighboring countries such as China and South Korea."

Supporters of Showa Day said it would cause the nation to reflect on the upheaval of the era and the accomplishments of rebuilding Japan during the postwar period of Hirohito's reign. Tsutomu Takebe, secretary general of the Liberal Democrats, told reporters on Friday that he did not expect negative reactions from China and South Korea. He argued that since the legislation was passed democratically, there should be understanding abroad.

Political analysts say the shift toward new assertiveness in foreign policy is fueled by mounting security fears in Japan. North Korea claims to have nuclear weapons, and China is building its military might.

Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi has been giving the Japanese military, known officially as the Self-Defense Forces, a new international role, including the dispatch of non-combat troops to Iraq in Japan's largest military operation since World War II.

But honoring Hirohito -- who was once considered divine, but rescinded that status after Japan's capitulation to the United States in 1945 -- with a national holiday is still considered a touchy subject. After his death in 1989, his birthday was marked with an ambiguous holiday called "Greenery Day."

hyaku
23rd May 2005, 08:47
But this day (29th) is already a National Holiday. When the new emperor took over we got December 23 off for the new Emperors birthday.
Showa Ten's birthday is called Midori no Hi (Green day).

Seems what they will do is tag on green day to golden week. To add even more confusion Golden Week is a three day holiday. so now will get four.

The meanest thing about all these holidays is one never get days in lieu.

If a holiday falls on a Sunday "tough luck".

Troll Basher
23rd May 2005, 08:51
Seems like another attempt at the Japanese to gloss over Showa Emps role in the war if you ask me.

heresjonny
15th June 2005, 13:32
Why shouldn't Japan gloss over it's past?

Everyone else does!

Take China, the current regime claims its legitimacy from Mao Tse-tung.

That man killed enough to make Hitler's work look like a childs-play, most of them fellow Communists.

As for playing an international role, why can't Japan do what the USA has been doing since WWII?

Moenstah
16th June 2005, 06:24
Why shouldn't Japan gloss over it's past?

Everyone else does!

Take China, the current regime claims its legitimacy from Mao Tse-tung.

That man killed enough to make Hitler's work look like a childs-play, most of them fellow Communists.

As for playing an international role, why can't Japan do what the USA has been doing since WWII?

Simply put; because Germany did too. They started a war and misery of a nearly unprecedented scale, so at least they should acknowledge that they were wrong.

It amazes me time and again to see how the Japanese try to deny or even justify their warcrimes. Quite silly really, since everyone knows what they've done.

Luckily there are states in Asia that can and do raise their voices against Japan, because the Europeans who were victims of the Japanese aggression are dying out.

PS: losers must apologize for their crimes, victors don't: vae victis

renfield_kuroda
16th June 2005, 08:59
Remi, don't over generalize. The Japanese have apologized, officially, for WWII and various related war crimes, specifically in China, several times. Most recently PM Koizumi explicitly apologized about Japan's actions in China and once again proclaimed Japan's unfettered support for human rights, etc. Did China show that on the news at all, even one little bit?
There are always many sides to a story; China has a huge agenda of using Japan as a scape goat. Best way to avoid criticism of your own gov't is to aim all that vitrol at someone else. Funny thing is, after all those protests in China started to seriously affect the economy and exports/imports, the gov't shut it down right quick.
The Chinese are anything if practical. And in closing, if China is on such a moral high horse, I got one word: Tibet.

Regards,
r e n

Moenstah
16th June 2005, 09:32
You’re right Ren, China’s hands are quite dirty as well (but which government has clean ones in this world?). Reading back my post, I realize that I’ve been influenced by the way my nation generally views the way Japan treated the Dutch they took prisoner in Indonesia (then: Dutch Indies) and the effects the Japanese occupation had on the growing nationalism of the Indonesians. I immediately admit the latter were completely right, but all this still has led to a profound (perhaps too?) critical point of view regarding the Japanese conduct in the war, and an anti-Hirohito sentiment in particular over here, even on an unconscious level.

Still, inserting the names of war criminals in that memorial shrine isn’t a particularly nice thing to do, let alone the government doing nothing about it. Imagine the name of Albert Speer being inserted on a German war memorial?

heresjonny
16th June 2005, 10:39
I neither condone nor condemn the Japanese treatment of prisoners in the war. Whilst the way the POWs were treated was undeniably wrong, the cause came more from a misunderstanding than from some deep inner sadism in the japanese people. The Japanese soldiers had know war with no prisoners and no surrender. The whole concept of "giving up" seemed beyond belief and so they came to see POWs as sub-human. This was not helped by the militaristic gov't of the time which taught children that they were racially superior. Whilst there undoubtedly are racial differences, to grow thinking you are the creme de la creme of humanity is not a healthy thing.

In terms of death tolls, China's hands are dirtier than Japan's and Germany's put together. Mao's cultural revolution was more recent than WWII and it isn't as if all those chinese are an less dead.

renfield_kuroda
16th June 2005, 11:15
P.M. Koizumi, when asked in the Diet about his stance regarding China, replied (I paraphrase):
There is an ancient Chinese proverb: "Do not forgive the crime, but do forgive the criminal."
How many names on the Vietnam War Memorial in Washington, D.C. belonged to men who did horrible things in a time of war? Or the US Civial War? Or the Revolutionary War? Or any other memorial for any other war?

War is a terrible, bloody, ugly thing in which soldiers do terrible, bloody, ugly things. But the inability to move on is a worse crime against humanity.

Regards,
r e n

Moenstah
30th June 2005, 14:49
I still regard the role of Hirohito too controversial for any "holiday festivities". Although he wasn't the prime motor/actor in the war, his hands aren't clean either (comparible to the role of president Von Hindenburg)