Wow!!! What the heck happened?
Things look pretty pitiful on this forum. Let me try and spark some convo...
Although many karateka and masters alike, claim that Shorin in very linear in form and technique, why is it that some ryuha (Kobayashi, Matsumura Orthodox) teach a crescent-stepping pattern whereas Matsubayashi and others teach a linear-stepping pattern? Does the classification only apply to hand techs or is the description indicative of all precepts within a system? What are the advantages and disadvantages of both, if any?
What is your guys' take on this training subtlety?
Later...
shorin ryu straight stepping
Kuda Yuichi shinshii used a straight step in Matsumura Kenpo-the one in which the lead foot turns 45 degrees first. However, in our version of rohai, we use a (albeit mild) circular step.
We do not have sanchin and sesan in our kata.
Kuda shinshii told me directly that he got the straight step from Soken.
j