The sad fact, in the case of judo or “modern”/gaijin/goshin jutsu –jujutsu forms, is that priniciples are often lost. The same has been found to be true in various other forms of martial arts. While this is often attributable to “sportification,” all too often it was the result of a focus on a particular aspect (competition/sport) that lead to this.
In the case of judo, while the Koshiki no Kata are still part of the judo curriculum, very few instructors teach them or require them; indeed, for a martial art/sport with such a well catalogued syllabus as judo, the requirements for each rank vary from dojo to dojo, association to association, and country to country. As for the Koshiki no Kata, or “Forms of Antiquity,” I believe it has often been disregarded because of its relation to koryu principles and applications. Because the forms are intended for grappling in armour,
it is essential that one practice them with the feel of wearing heavy armour-or wearing armour, both of which are rather difficult. Dr. Kano preserved these techniques because of the principles they embody, but they have been disgarded by many for irrelevance.
Anyone who is fortunate enough to have experience with them knows that not only are the principles relevant, but only has to wear restrictive clothing, such as a three-piece suit, to see how practical they can be.
The same can found to be true in many other martial arts/sports and even in the practice of some koryu, not only because of simple disregard, but often because the applications and principles have been lost or untransmitted in that particular line.
Question:"Why do we do it that way, Sensei?"
Answer: "Because we do." or "Because we always have" or, if you're lucky,"I don't know."
How many applications/principles are embodied in simple gestures/salutes/foot placement/steps/head turns in your art? Does your instructor point them out?
If not, are they truly lost, or merely there waiting to be rediscovered, either through other instruction, insight or personal experience.
I'd say I agree and disagree. The principles and applications that formed judo are still present, it becomes a question of focus and quality of instruction/knowledge/insight.The same could be said about the bunkai of various karate kata, or even the way that one bows.
Aaron J. Cuffee
As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron.
- H.L. Mencken