Originally Posted by
Lance Gatling
But my point is how long it would get from zero battlefield utility, just handed a sword or jo, to the point where you could defend yourself and be of some use to the common effort.
I have a paper written by my sword instructor in which he notes that it has been traditionally taught in Jikishinkage Ryu that it takes a minimum of three years of training before a student can be expected to survive on the battlefield. I've been meaning to ask him if that means three years of training on a daily basis, or if the three years is a modern rule of thumb developed since the time when most people stopped training as if their lives depend on it.
If it's just basic battlefield functionality that we're looking for, though, I think that it could be achieved a bit faster than that-- if we are training peasants to fight with a spear, we are mainly going to be teaching them to march in formation, to hold ranks, and to thrust correctly. We're not looking for them to win duels, we're looking for them to form a wall of sharpened steel. It would be great if you had three years to drill the peasants in that sort of thing, but a few months would probably be enough to teach them the basics. As far as sword work goes, I imagine that you would probably take a page from Jigen Ryu's training manual and hand each farmer a big stick, stand him in front of a tree, and have him whack the tree as hard as possible while screaming at the top of his lungs. After a few weeks of that sort of thing, if you teach him some basic drills-- all of which would involve him charging the enemy and cutting at an exposed bit of body-- he would probably be ready for the front lines. He wouldn't be able to beat a skilled swordsman, but he would be able to become part of a charging mass of screaming fighters.
Of course, the longer you have to train them, the better, but the point is that for basic functionality on the battlefield, I think you are looking less for skill and more for the ability to hold ranks and go towards the enemy, rather than running away. If your conscripts stand fast and attack, your skilled troops-- the ones who have spent years honing their skills-- will have an opportunity to bring their abilities into play.
David Sims
"Cuius testiculos habes, habeas cardia et cerebellum." - Terry Pratchet
My opinion is, in all likelihood, worth exactly what you are paying for it.