Ok, now that I have had a chance to breath, I was looking at
different clips of Seisan. Like Passai, Kusanku and in some cases Gojushiho,
I noticed there were two distinct versions. One originating from Naha,
and the other which looks like a Tomari version. Knowing that there are a lot
of kata collectors out there, why haven't these become known as a sho and
dai version? Should they be known as Naha and Tomari Seisan? I know
Matsumura practiced Seisan. I also know that Chibana did not have this
as part of his syllabus. Could this be because with the practice of the
Pinans, Seisan became redundant?
Thoughts?