Likes:
0
-
1st September 2010, 02:54
#16
I thought I'd throw my 2 cents in as an ex-pat Aussie who has been around the koryu and jujutsu traps for a while. I don't personally know Mr Waters, but want to contribute some deductive information for people's consideration. Mr Waters is teaching a modern art called Glen-ryu - all the more power to him there - but claims to have training in Sekiguchi-ryu in the past. Most of the conjecture here is about the claim to Sekiguchi-ryu training.
First: Ben's link indicates Mr Waters has been associated with the "Australian Jujitsu Association" at some point. Much of what I am aware of regarding the background to this association can be found on this e-budo jujutsu thread. Please note that Sekiguchi-ryu is not mentioned here.
Secondly: None of the branches of Sekiguchi-ryu currently in existance in Japan publically list any Australian groups studying under them. Even Sekiguchi-ryu footage can be found on public Internet sites like YouTube these days, allowing prospective students to compare a prospective teacher and the art s/he claims to teach as practiced in Japan.
Thirdly: Whenever someone makes a public claim to teach a traditional martial art, I personally expect several questions to be answered by them -
1. Who was their teacher and what is their lineage?
2. How long did they study, and what rank did they receive?
3. What third-party verifiable evidence can be provided?
The responsiblity is thus on the person making claims to back them up with evidence.
My 2 cents.
Last edited by Daniel Lee; 1st September 2010 at 02:59.
Daniel Lee
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules