View Full Version : kagami-migaki

len mccoy
3rd May 2019, 23:14
I was thinking about this the other day and something jumped out at me.
My understanding is that kagami-migaki comes from Tenshinshinryo ryu and was incorporated into Judo's Tandoku Renshu by Kano Sensei as an attempt to pay some respect to the old ways. All I have seen of it is the pictures In the book Kodokan Judo by Kano copyright 1986 (Kano was long dead when it came out) and a few youtube videos probably based on trying to imitate the book.
Elbows flare out and there is no visible raising and lowering the torso.

Anyway I was thinking I had seen mirror polishing elsewhere and the I remember Marshall Ho'o's book Tai Chi Chuan the last of his temple exercises is mirror polishing. Once more I have the book and some youtube videos. Elbows are pointed down (essential for a Tai Chi movement) and the body definitely moves up and down.
My first guess would be just a coincidence. Mirror polishing is a metaphor for internal reflecting even in the west.
But is anyone in a position to clarify how similar or
dis-similar Kano's mirror polishing is to the original? Is the original allowed to be shown in public?

Does anyone know the origin of Marshall Ho'o's Temple exercises?

I am not asking anyone to divulge secrets but if this is information you are allowed to share I am very interested.

Len McCoy

Cady Goldfield
4th May 2019, 04:27
I think those exercises come mostly from Yang style taiji chuan. From what I see of the exercises described by Marshall Ho'o. they are "omote" or "shoden" level, meaning they are about posture/alignment and overt-muscle driven movement. There's nothing I can see that could be considered "internal." The only mention of anything related to internal method in these drills, is a brief point to "root the feet to the ground," but, of course, without explaining what that is. ;)